The experiment was a success. However, although Furrer was satisfied that it would have been possible to build a sword of this quality in the Viking age, he remained puzzled as to how the Vikings got hold of the steel. “The biggest mystery is where did they get this raw material,” Furrer told Nova. “We have no evidence of crucible steel production in Europe until 800 years later.” According to Fredrik Charpentier Ljungqvist, a researcher at Stockholm University, the answer may be quite simple. The existence of the Damascus swords prove that, while the expertise to create crucible steel did not yet exist in Europe, it was present in the Middle East. Meanwhile, artifacts found at archeological sites from the Viking era prove that the Medieval Norsemen traded with the East. We also know that they could travel by water – on rivers and lakes – all the way from Lake Mälaren outside modern-day Stockholm to northern Iran. The route was known as the Volga trade route.
“Most Ulfberht swords are dated from the exact same time that the Volga trade route was open,” Charpentier Ljungqvist told Nova. “I think it’s very likely that the steel found in Ulfberht swords originated in Iran. I would guess that you bought it from friendly trading connections in Iran, paid with furs or other Nordic commodities, and took it back on your small ships that you used on rivers.” Dr. Alan Williams of the Wallace Collection in London is one of the world’s leading experts on historic steel weaponry. Williams agrees with Charpentier Ljungqvist: “After the 11th century, the Volga trade route is closed and the manufacture of these Ulfberht swords stops, which to me is strong evidence that they were made out of an imported raw material,” he explained.